Since we are allowed to enter as many entries as we want into the Secret 7" competition, I've decided to do another design because I also really liked the song "Reflections" by Diana Ross and the Supremes.
This once again began with me listening to the lyrics of the song and illustrating what I felt it communicated. The key motifs I've picked out from the lyrics are the loss of time, love and happiness.
I thumbnailed a few initial ideas depicting a mirror which is radiating or holding all the concepts the song is singing about:
I like the idea of there being a woman looking through the mirror with white space all around, and her seeing all the things she lost within it.
I then did a more developed version of the mirror in watercolour, and laid it out as a test - the black corner lines are only there because I thought it might be interesting to have something else going on in the cover but I don't think it's really worth keeping, as I quite like the mirror being the sole object on the cover.
I also re-drew the woman digitally and tried to give her dress a sparkly look like most of the motown dresses the artists would use when performing their songs
After vectorizing the watercolour drawing of the mirror, I coloured it in Photoshop and applied a texture since I didn't want to have the soulless look of flat vector colours.
I tried removing the line work for the hearts, the hearts and flowers, and removing it altogether. In the end I decided to remove only certain lines in order to attain a nice compositional balance - I feel that the lines made certain areas 'heavier' than others.
I was left with 4 main compositional options:
I feel like the first composition packs the most punch because it reaches the edges of the cover, but feels quite constrained. Incorporating the woman into the design, I realized that the perspective of the mirror and her (particularly her placed hand) is completely off. I stretched the mirror out so it's a bit more correct, but I still think it looks a bit strange.
In the end, I compromised between the first and second - make the mirror smaller but move the shapes so they reach off the page in order to fill out the composition. I think the woman could potentially have worked if I had drawn her and the mirror together, rather than separately and then hoping they would fit together.
However at the same time, I think she makes an otherwise simple concept/design a lot weaker.